[Tanya] Di TOlak DOAJ

Kolom untuk diskusi mengenai tata kelola jurnal baik berupa pengalaman dari instansi ataupun pribadi anggota.
Post Reply
bianconeri
Posts: 34
Joined: 31 Dec 2016, 19:17
Location: Yogyakarta
Contact:

[Tanya] Di TOlak DOAJ

Post by bianconeri »

Teman-teman saya mendaftarkan 2 Jurnal Ke DOAJ.
Hari ini dapat email bahwa di tolak dan disuruh daftar lagi, pertanyaan saya apakah kedua jurnal saya ditolak semua atau hanya satu?

ini isi pesanya

Dear Editor,

Your application for DOAJ has been auto-rejected since all questions had been answered with the same url.
Please reapply with a specific url for the information asked for in the application form.

Kind Regards

ajienoorseto
Posts: 449
Joined: 30 Dec 2016, 21:19
Contact:

Re: Di TOlak DOAJ

Post by ajienoorseto »

saya kurang tau pak, tp ketika pendaftaran url jurnal apakah sama? klo multi jurnal biasa beda sih, tapi depannya sama

misal :
portaljurnal.com/index.php/jurnalA
portaljurnal.con/index.php/jurnalB

atau mungkin dibuat nama domain sendiri
jurnalA.portaljurnal.com
jurnalB.portaljurnal.com

atau ketika pendaftaran kemarin menggunakan 1 email yg sama

atau mungkin tanya lagi ke doaj, maksudnya same url itu apa
Atom Indonesia
http://aij.batan.go.id

ajienoorseto
Posts: 449
Joined: 30 Dec 2016, 21:19
Contact:

Re: Di TOlak DOAJ

Post by ajienoorseto »

One URL per site. One dedicated page to the journal.
When a journal gets indexed it will have its own record in the Directory. To make our service comprehensible and user-friendly, the link to a journal from the Directory must go straight to a homepage for the journal and not to a collection of journals or any other service. Whether the URL is a dedicated domain or a sub-domain does not matter; but the journal must have an online space dedicated to it only. For example: http://www.thisisajournal.com or http://www.publishersite.com/journals/thisisajournal or http://www.mycollege.org/thisisajournal are all acceptable. http://www.largesearchengine.com that includes journal content is not accepted. This is a basic requirement for entry into DOAJ.

All the necessary journal business information pages (by 'business information pages', we mean the journal's aims and scope, the editorial board, the instructions for authors, the description of the quality control system, the Open Access statement, the plagiarism policy, and the licensing terms) must be hosted on this same site and not be held centrally on another web site, or must be prominently linked to from the journal's homepage. This is a basic requirement for entry into DOAJ. This applies particularly to multi-journal publishers who may prefer to hold generic information on a corporate website rather than locally on each journal site. Our insistence on this approach makes it easier for visitors to your sites to find specific journal information correctly. Do not assume that visitors to a journal will automatically understand that the journal belongs to a larger group of journals or to a specific publisher, or that important information is held elsewhere. Neither should it be taken for granted that users will search for the necessary information that they need to carry out a full assessment of your journal. It is your responsibility to ensure that the information pages are findable, easily accessible, up to date and relevant.

DOAJ also requests that a journal has its own dedicated website. No other service or product should be present under that URL. All the journal content that the publisher is including in the application must be in one place and not spread over various locations. This includes archive material. This is a basic requirement for entry into DOAJ.

https://doaj.org/publishers
Atom Indonesia
http://aij.batan.go.id

andri.putra.kesmawan
Posts: 252
Joined: 31 Dec 2016, 19:19
Location: Yogyakarta
Contact:

Re: [Tanya] Di TOlak DOAJ

Post by andri.putra.kesmawan »

1 jurnal biasanya mas. Cek lg emailnya, yg ditolak yg jurnal mana ada info di email itu.
Andri Putra Kesmawan
Ketua Dewan Pengawas Relawan Jurnal Indonesia
andri.putra.k@mail.ugm.ac.id
https://andriputra.web.ugm.ac.id

ratodi
Posts: 47
Joined: 31 Dec 2016, 07:20
Location: Surabaya
Contact:

Re: [Tanya] Di TOlak DOAJ

Post by ratodi »

Submit 2 jurnalnya berbarengan kah waktunya?
Muhamad Ratodi
Universitas Islam Negeri Sunan Ampel Surabaya
www.mratodi.com
mratodi@uinsby.ac.id

bianconeri
Posts: 34
Joined: 31 Dec 2016, 19:17
Location: Yogyakarta
Contact:

Re: [Tanya] Di TOlak DOAJ

Post by bianconeri »

ratodi wrote:Submit 2 jurnalnya berbarengan kah waktunya?
iya dalam waktu bersamaan :cry: :cry: :cry: :cry:

jurnalqof17
Posts: 2
Joined: 23 Nov 2018, 01:02

Re: [Tanya] Di TOlak DOAJ

Post by jurnalqof17 »

Mohon pencerahan teman-teman, apa yg harus kami lakukan setelah ditolak DOAJ. Isi email-nya begini.

Thank you for your application to list this journal in DOAJ (Directory of Open Access Journals). Unfortunately your application has been unsuccessful, as the journal does not meet the minimum criteria for inclusion in DOAJ. No open access statement is provided, and your copyright notice appears to be more restrictive than permitted by the chosen Creative Commons license.

If you wish to apply again in future, you may do so after 6 months. Before you submit another application, make sure you have read the following material: http://doaj.org/bestpractice and http://doaj.org/publishers and have made changes to your journal and website in order to meet the DOAJ criteria. If you have any questions about any of the information on those pages, please send an email to feedback@doaj.org.

ciptoblues
Posts: 39
Joined: 08 Jan 2018, 11:24

Re: [Tanya] Di TOlak DOAJ

Post by ciptoblues »

jurnalqof17 wrote:Mohon pencerahan teman-teman, apa yg harus kami lakukan setelah ditolak DOAJ. Isi email-nya begini.

Thank you for your application to list this journal in DOAJ (Directory of Open Access Journals). Unfortunately your application has been unsuccessful, as the journal does not meet the minimum criteria for inclusion in DOAJ. No open access statement is provided, and your copyright notice appears to be more restrictive than permitted by the chosen Creative Commons license.

If you wish to apply again in future, you may do so after 6 months. Before you submit another application, make sure you have read the following material: http://doaj.org/bestpractice and http://doaj.org/publishers and have made changes to your journal and website in order to meet the DOAJ criteria. If you have any questions about any of the information on those pages, please send an email to feedback@doaj.org.
Submit setelah 6 bulan kemudian. Pastikan sudah memperbaiki sesuai arahan email dari DOAJ

Post Reply